The Vampire Diaries handsome Paul Wesley (Stefan) and The Originals beauty Phoebe Tonkin (Hayley) were spotted in New York City. The paparazzi spot them walking in NYC’s SoHo neighborhood Friday afternoon (Nov 29). The rumored couple walk through the city with another man. Paul and Phoebe share a snack as they go and then hail a cab. It’s hard to tell where they are going to or coming from, but it appears they’re dressed causally. Paul sports jeans and Phoebe seems to be wearing black tights and a skirt or dress. Perhaps the pair are off somewhere to visit friends or family together. After all, Paul is from New Jersey. Take a look at the photos of Paul Wesley & Phoebe Tonkin below.